Pets Plus Shopify store on laptop and phone: 98% higher average order value, 2.53x ROAS, 17% subscriptions

Pet Brand Digital Marketing & Shopify Case Study | Pets Plus

client

Pets Plus Digital Marketing

services

Monthly Digital Marketing Management

Meta Ads

Email Marketing (Klaviyo)

SEO & AEO

Shopify Maintenance

year

2026

Location: Bemidji, Minnesota

In short: Pets Plus, a family-owned pet store and premium pet food brand founded in 1992, hired InkRoast in July 2026 to run its online growth every month: ads, email, SEO and its Shopify store. Since then, average order value has risen 98%, and paid ads returned 2.53x their cost 90 days after launch.


Results

  • +98% average order value
  • 2.53x return on ad spend, 90 days after launch (all customers)
  • 17% subscription share
  • 7% email share


About the Client

Pets Plus started in Jim and Mary Joy’s garage in 1992 and has served pet owners from its Bemidji store since 1998. It sells online at mypetsplus.com, supplies wholesale buyers, and owns the North Winds Premium dog and cat food line. InkRoast has designed its brand, packaging and Shopify store since 2019.


The Challenge

  • A strong local reputation that wasn’t yet turning into steady online growth
  • Store updates, offers and wholesale rules handled ad hoc instead of on a plan
  • No single monthly view of ads, email, subscriptions and search performance


What We Do Every Month

  • Plan: a monthly plan in 5W1H format (who, what, when, where, why, how), approved by Pets Plus before work starts
  • Paid ads: a monthly media plan and budget proposal, campaign builds and optimization; no spend without client approval
  • Email: 2–4 Klaviyo campaigns a month, including Local Store Specials, plus list hygiene and subscription reporting
  • SEO & AEO: keyword map for priority chew categories, on-page fixes and monthly ranking reports
  • Shopify maintenance: monthly offers, discounts and events, wholesale minimum and freight tiers, speed fixes and tracking
  • Brand consistency: one official name for the North Winds Premium line across sites, social and marketplaces
  • Reporting: one consolidated performance report each month


Why It Works

One partner owns the store, the ads and the email list, so every campaign lands on a page built for it and every result is measured in one place. The work runs on a monthly rhythm, not on emergencies.

Pets Plus Shopify store on a tablet
No items found.
Pets Plus Shopify homepage
Pets Plus Shopify homepage product sections
No items found.

Pets Plus has trusted InkRoast since 2019, first with branding and packaging, then with its Shopify store, and since July 2026 with its full monthly marketing. That history is the advantage: the team running the ads already knows the products, the customers and the North Woods story behind the brand.

Pets Plus mobile store
North Winds Premium brand image with a dog and owner outdoors
No items found.

Since July 2026 InkRoast runs Pets Plus’s ads, email, SEO and Shopify every month: average order value up 98%, and 2.53x return on ad spend 90 days after launch.

Pets Plus store page
Pets Plus product page
Pets Plus collection page
No items found.

have an idea for a project or starting your roasting process?

Get in touch

arrow right
+